Giselle and I shared the exact same birthday. Our parents had been close friends since college, which meant our lives were tangled together long before either of us had a say in the matter. Giselle was radiant, quick-witted, and effortlessly charming. Every year, when our joint celebration rolled around, the entire room naturally gravitated toward her, leaving me hovering in the shadowy periphery like an uninvited guest. When I was ten, I finally gathered the nerve to whisper to my parents that I didn’t want to share a birthday anymore. They shut me down before I could even finish the sentence. “Giselle gets straight A’s and leads the school choir,” my mother scolded, her voice laced with disappointment. “You should be trying to learn from her, not throwing a fit.” “And she actually knows how to speak to adults,” my father added, shaking his head. “She greets everyone with a smile. You stand there like a mute wallflower. Who’s going to like a girl who doesn’t even try?” This year, for our twenty-fourth birthday, I built up enough courage to bring my boyfriend, Galen, home to meet my parents for the first time. Twenty minutes into the party, I offered to run down to the lobby convenience store to buy a lighter for the candles. On my way down, the elevator shuddered violently, dropped two full floors, and jammed between levels. The emergency call button gave nothing but a hollow dial tone. My phone screen flashed red—one percent battery remaining. With shaking hands, I dialed Galen. Once. Twice. Five times. He never picked up. It took an hour for the fire department to force the doors open and pull me out into the hallway, where I collapsed on the tile, gasping for air. When I finally dragged myself back up to the apartment, my parents were clustered around Giselle in the living room. Galen was standing a few feet away, holding up his camera, directing her poses under the warm glow of the fairy lights. One of my cousins glanced toward the doorway and spoke up. “Hey, Galen, Val tried calling you a bunch of times. Might be urgent.” Galen didn’t even lower his camera. His brow furrowed in visible annoyance. “God, can’t she give it a rest for one night?” he muttered. “Giselle, tilt your chin up slightly—yes, just like that. Stunning.” I stood frozen at the threshold. Cold sweat had plastered my hair to my forehead, and my hands were shaking so hard I could barely hold my purse. Looking at the scene in front of me, something inside my chest went completely still. If, in their eyes, I was always going to be the dull, invisible shadow next to Giselle’s golden light—then I didn’t want any of them anymore. … Giselle stood beneath the string lights in a tailored champagne cocktail dress. Her makeup was soft and polished, her dark hair styled into glossy, loose waves. My father couldn’t stop beaming at her. “Giselle gets more gorgeous every year. You look like a movie star, sweetheart.” “Doesn’t she?” my mother agreed warmly, clasping her hands together. “So much more elegant than our Valerie! Val was such a cute baby, like a little porcelain doll. Who knew she’d turn out so plain? She didn’t inherit a single good gene from either of us.” She sighed, half-joking, half-wistful. “If only Giselle were my daughter.” I had heard variations of these words my entire life. I wasn’t striking, I wasn’t glamorous, and if you placed me in a crowd, I was the kind of person your eyes would slip right past. I thought I had grown immune to the sting over the years, but hearing it again tonight, right outside the room, made a sharp, familiar ache blossom behind my ribs. I swallowed the lump in my throat, forced my chin up, and walked into the living room. Someone finally noticed me. “Oh, Val’s back!” Galen turned around, his eyes locking onto mine. There was no relief in his face—only immediate frustration. “It was just a lighter, Val. What took you so long?” he demanded, his voice carrying over the music. “Everyone’s been waiting on you. You never take anything seriously.” I stared at him, keeping my voice as steady as I could. “Galen, I was trapped in the building elevator. For a full hour.” He blinked, caught off guard. “What? Why didn’t you call me?” A bitter laugh escaped my chest. “Why didn’t I? I called you five times until my battery died.” I pulled my dark, lifeless phone out of my pocket and tossed it onto the sofa cushion. “Or were you too busy taking photos of Giselle to care?” A flicker of panic crossed Galen’s face. “My phone was on silent. I didn’t see it.” I pulled my lips into a cold, hollow smile. Galen stepped toward me, softening his tone in a display of sudden patience. “Alright, don’t be dramatic. It’s Giselle’s birthday, and since photography is my hobby, I just offered to snap a couple of shots for her.” Giselle glided over, her eyes glistening with delicate tears. “Val, I’m so sorry. It’s all my fault,” she whimpered gently. “I had no idea you were trying to reach Galen. Please don’t be mad at him—he was just being sweet. I know you wanted photos too, even though your makeup looks a little… unfinished today. But that’s okay! Once he’s done taking mine, I can help you edit yours before we cut the cake.” My gaze drifted past her shoulder toward the dining table. The cake was elaborate—a two-tiered masterpiece frosted in pistachio green, decorated with delicate sugar butterflies and shimmering chocolate pearls. It was Giselle’s favorite aesthetic. And knowing her, the inside was undoubtedly filled with fresh mangoes. Giselle loved mangoes. I was severely allergic to them. And today was my birthday, too. Not a single person in the room remembered. “Come on, Val,” Galen said, reaching out to grab my hand. “It’s our birthday night. Don’t ruin the mood over nothing…” I took a step back, letting his hand fall empty into the air. His eyebrows pulled together instantly. “What is that supposed to mean?” “It means I’m done,” I said quietly. It wasn’t just about the lighter, or the elevator, or the photos. It was about him. It was about all of them. I pulled the lighter from my jacket pocket, set it quietly on the side table, grabbed my dead phone, and turned on my heel toward the front door. Galen caught up to me in the hallway outside. “Val! Stop!” he called out, sounding thoroughly annoyed. “Why are you throwing a fit? Just because I wasn’t there to pry the elevator doors open myself?” I kept walking toward the exit. He let out a sharp, exasperated breath. “Even if I had picked up the phone, all I could have done was call building maintenance anyway! Why are you making such a massive deal out of a minor inconvenience? Just come back inside and cut the cake. Giselle is waiting.” “Giselle. Giselle. Giselle.” Her name rolled off his tongue like a habit he didn’t even realize he had formed. I didn’t say another word. I pressed the button for the stairs and hurried down without looking back. When I reached my small rented apartment, I plugged my phone into the wall. The moment the screen flickered to life, it began ringing. It was my mother. I declined the call. She called again immediately. Then a third time. Then a fourth. I took a deep, shaky breath and tapped answer. My mother’s voice exploded through the speaker before I could even say hello. “Valerie! Have you completely lost your mind?” she yelled. “Everyone is sitting here waiting for you to cut the cake, and you just walk out without saying a word to anyone?” I sat on the edge of my unmade bed, still wearing my jacket. My ankles ached terribly from standing in the cramped elevator for an hour. “Did you only just notice I left?” I asked softly. The line went quiet for a beat. Then my father’s heavy, stern voice cut through. “We came here tonight to celebrate both of you, and you insisted on pulling a face from the moment you walked in,” he snapped. “Now you’ve stomped off to play the victim, leaving Giselle in tears! She feels so guilty she can’t even stop crying!” “Giselle cries, and the whole world stops to comfort her,” I blurted out, my voice breaking. “I was trapped in a tiny, suffocating box for an hour, terrified out of my mind—and neither of you gave a damn! Did either of you even ask if I was okay?” “Well, you’re sitting at home talking to us, aren’t you?” my mother snapped impatiently. “You got delayed in an elevator, big deal! You’re acting like someone assaulted you! Get back over here right now. If you want to throw a tantrum, do it after we cut the cake!” “You are becoming more unmanageable every single day!” my father added coldly. “How did we end up with a daughter like you?” Tears spilled over my lashes, hot and sudden, burning down my cheeks. “Giselle is pretty, so she stands in the center of every photograph,” I sobbed, my entire body trembling. “She knows how to flatter you, so you love her more. What about me? When I was eight, there was only one candle on the cake, and you let Giselle blow it out. When I was twelve, Giselle wanted the new dress you bought me, and you made me hand it over because ‘she looked prettier in it.’ And tonight—tonight I brought Galen home for the first time, and you seated him next to her because you were afraid “he’d” be bored talking to me! He is “my” boyfriend!” I scrubbed at my face with the back of my sleeve, but the tears kept coming. “My entire life, I’ve had to share my birthday with her. Whenever I asked for my own cake, you said I was being selfish. Whenever I wanted a flavor I actually liked, you told me to stop being difficult. Today wasn’t just Giselle’s birthday—it was mine too! Just because I’m not as pretty or as loud, why do I have to surrender every shred of love and attention to her? Why?” The silence on the other end of the line was absolute. Heavy, unnatural, and suffocating. After a few agonizing seconds, I heard a faint, awkward cough from one of my aunts in the background. Then, my mother’s panicked, hushed voice hissed into the microphone: “What kind of crazy nonsense are you talking about?” My throat closed up. A moment later, Giselle’s tremulous, tear-soaked voice drifted through the speaker. “Val… I had no idea you hated me this much,” she sobbed softly. “If my presence makes you so miserable, I—I won’t ever celebrate my birthday again. Please don’t be mad at your parents. Don’t be mad at Galen…” My heart plummeted into my stomach. They had put me on speakerphone. Every raw, humiliating truth I had buried for over a decade—my pathetic jealousy, my crushing insecurity, my deepest resentments—had just been broadcast to a room packed with relatives and family friends. They had heard every pathetic word. I gripped the phone so hard my knuckles turned ghostly white. All my life, my biggest fear was letting people see how inadequate Giselle made me feel. I had fought so hard to hide my envy because I was terrified of looking ugly in front of others. But now, the mask was gone. There was nothing left to save. I took a shaky breath and let the bitterness flood my voice. “You’re right, Giselle. I do hate you,” I said, leaning close to the receiver. “I hate the way you take everything that belongs to me and then cry like you’re the victim. And I hate how you play the delicate angel so that whenever I get hurt, I’m the one who looks cruel.” “Valerie!” my mother screamed through the phone. I ended the call. I sat on the edge of the mattress in the dark, my face drenched in tears, shaking uncontrollably. It took a long time for the tremors in my hands to stop. When they finally did, I wiped my cheeks, stood up, and pulled my rolling suitcase out from under the bed. By the time Galen arrived at my apartment, I had already packed my clothes. He pushed the door open, breathless, and froze when his eyes landed on the open luggage on the floor. Panic flickered in his eyes. “Val? What are you doing?” I kept my back to him, zipping up my toiletries bag. “I’m leaving.” “Because I missed your phone calls?” he asked, stepping closer. I pulled my ID and wallet out of my desk drawer and slid them into my purse. “It was never about a phone call, Galen.” “Then what is it?” He stepped into my line of sight, blocking me. “Because of Giselle?” He looked down at me, his expression softening into an almost condescending tenderness. “Val, I know I messed up tonight, okay? I’m sorry. Please don’t do this. There’s nothing going on between me and Giselle. You went down to get a lighter, I had nothing to do, so I took a couple of shots for her. I was going to take yours as soon as you came back.” I didn’t answer him. Galen let out a long sigh and rubbed the back of his neck. “Look, Val… what you said over the phone tonight was really out of line. The elevator breaking down wasn’t Giselle’s fault. You shouldn’t have taken your anger out on her.” I looked up, meeting his eyes. “So you came all the way here to defend her honor?” Galen caught himself, pinching the bridge of his nose in frustration. “That’s not what I’m saying. I know you were shaken up by being trapped. But you need to step back and ask yourself “why” everyone loves Giselle so much.” My fingers went stiff against my purse strap. He continued, his tone smooth, like a adult trying to reason with an unreasonable child. “She doesn’t steal things from you, Val. She’s just warm, easygoing, and knows how to make people feel comfortable. And you?” He sighed gently. “You’re always so closed off. You wear those oversized, drab gray clothes that make you blend into the walls. Today was your birthday, and you wore a plain, baggy T-shirt. Look at Giselle—she knows how to dress for an occasion. And your makeup… it’s always a little off, isn’t it? Your blush makes you look bruised, and your brows are never quite even. You could really stand to learn a thing or two from her.” I listened to every single word, feeling the last tender place inside my heart go completely numb. My parents had spent my whole life telling me I was inferior to Giselle, that I needed to copy her if I ever wanted to be loved. I had foolishly believed that Galen was different—that he loved me for who I was. When I first brought him around my family, I had been terrified he would fall under Giselle’s spell. Back then, he had wrapped his arms around me and laughed softly: “What’s going on in that silly head of yours? To me, you’re the most beautiful girl in the world.” It was all a lie. He was no different from my parents. He didn’t love my mind, my spirit, or my heart. He just wanted a project—a rougher, quieter version of Giselle that he could mold into something presentable. It was exhausting. It was suffocating. I reached up, unclasped the thin silver ring Galen had given me on our one-year anniversary, and set it softly on the wooden nightstand. “Let’s break up, Galen.” He stared at the ring, then back at me, as if I were speaking a foreign language. “What did you just say?” “I said, we’re done.” His face hardened instantly. “Are you seriously using a breakup to threaten me right now?” “I’m not threatening you,” I said quietly. “I’m telling you.” Before he could respond, the apartment door swung open. My parents walked in, followed closely by Giselle, who was clutching the uncut butterfly cake to her chest like a peace offering. Her eyes were red and swollen. My mother set the cake box down on the small coffee table with a loud thud. The moment she saw my suitcase, her expression darkened. “So you’re really pulling a runaway stunt?” My father stood by the door, arms crossed, his face cold. “You’ve got some nerve, Valerie. You humiliated us in front of the entire family tonight, and now you’re throwing a dramatic scene?” Giselle tugged gently at my mother’s sleeve, her voice soft and trembling. “Auntie, please don’t yell at Val… It’s her birthday too. She’s just hurt. It’s all my fault. I shouldn’t have let Galen take photos of me…” Tears spilled over her lashes right on cue. My mother immediately pulled Giselle into a protective embrace. “How could any of this be your fault? You’re always too sweet for your own good, Giselle. That’s why she thinks she can walk all over you. She’s bitter and unlovable, so she blames you for being better than her!” I stood there, looking at the four of them, and a quiet, terrible laugh bubbled up from my chest. “Mom,” I said softly. “Today is my birthday, too.” My mother froze. I pointed at the box on the table. “Why is there only one cake?” Her brows pulled together defensively. “You always said you didn’t care about—” “I cared!” I cut her off, my voice echoing against the thin walls of the apartment. “I cared every single year! I cared that the birthday song was only ever sung for her. I cared that you always bought her favorite flavor, completely forgetting that mangoes literally put me in the emergency room! I cared that when I was trapped in a dark elevator for an hour tonight, not one of you even noticed I was missing! And I cared that when I finally told you I was terrified and hurt, you called me dramatic and selfish!” My mother’s face turned blotchy. “Why do you always have to drag up ancient history?” My father stepped forward, furious. “No normal child acts the way you do! Giselle’s parents have been like family to us for twenty years, and you’re treating her like an enemy!” I looked past my father to Giselle. She was tucked safely against my mother’s shoulder, weeping delicately, playing the tragic victim to perfection. “Val,” Giselle sniffled, looking up at me with wide, pitiful eyes. “I never meant to take anything from you. If my presence hurts you this much, I’ll just stay away from your parents from now on…” “Look at what you’re doing to her!” my father roared, pointing a finger at my face. “You apologize to Giselle right now!” I clutched my suitcase handle tightly. “No.” “What did you say?” “I said no! I didn’t do anything wrong!” I yelled, the words tearing out of my chest. “I don’t like her, and I don’t like any of you! I hate sharing my life with her! I don’t want to see any of you ever again—” “SLAP.” The sharp crack echoed through the small room. My head snapped to the side, and a sudden, ringing stillness filled my ears. Everyone froze. Slowly, I raised a hand to touch my burning left cheek. The skin was hot and numb. But strange as it was, no tears came to my eyes. The well had completely run dry. My mother’s hand was still shaking in the air, but she braced herself, her chin trembling with anger. “That slap was to bring you to your senses! Valerie, how can a daughter be so malicious? Giselle was trying to have a nice birthday, and you ruined it on purpose!” Galen moved toward me, his voice cautious. “Val… your mom is just overwhelmed. Just apologize, okay? Let’s just get through tonight.” It was always like this. They hit me, and I had to apologize. They cast me aside, and I had to be the sensible one. For twenty-four years, I had played my part in their little play. I took a deep breath and closed my eyes. “Okay.” They all visibly relaxed, assuming I was finally caving in. Then I opened my eyes and looked directly at Galen. “Galen, I am officially breaking up with you.” I turned to my parents. “And as of tonight, I am cutting you out of my life.” My father let out a harsh sneer. “You wouldn’t dare! Valerie, you walk out that door tonight, and don’t you dare come crying back when you realize how hard the real world is!” I pulled up the handle of my suitcase, turned toward the open hallway, and walked out without looking back. Behind me, my mother’s voice cracked into an angry scream. “Go on then! Leave! See if we ever care again!” The heavy door slammed shut behind me, severing the warm light of the apartment. I stood alone in the dim hallway. My cheek was still throbbing with a dull, steady heat, but inside my chest, a tight, suffocating knot that had bound me since childhood suddenly snapped open. The elevator doors slid open in front of me, bright and empty. I stepped inside and pressed the button for the ground floor. As the doors drew together, I caught one last glimpse of the hallway, then closed my eyes. “Valerie,” I told myself quietly in the quiet hum of the descending cab, “from this moment on, you are the only person in the world who needs to love you.”
🌟 Continue the story here 👉🏻 📲 Download the “MotoNovel” app 🔍 search for “552793”, and watch the full series ✨! #MotoNovel
Leave a Reply